BA’s Best Piña Colada

A great piña colada should taste like pineapple first, coconut second, and rum all the way through. Here, fresh pineapple brings brightness and natural acidity, while a combination of cream of coconut and coconut milk delivers bold coconut flavor without tipping the drink into candy-sweet territory.

The blend-then-freeze-then-blend-again process takes a little planning, but it rewards you with the thick, slushy texture that sets a craveable piña colada apart from an ordinary one. Whether you’re serving them poolside, beachside, or just on a particularly hot afternoon, an extra float of dark rum, a cocktail umbrella, and a maraschino cherry never hurt.

FAQs

Why use both cream of coconut and coconut milk?

Cream of coconut provides the requisite sweetness and body for this drink, while coconut milk adds a concentrated boost of coconut flavor without adding more sugar. Using both creates a richer-tasting piña colada that’s balanced rather than cloying.

Can I use frozen pineapple instead of fresh?

Using a fresh, ripe pineapple delivers the brightest, most aromatic flavor, but frozen pineapple is a convenient shortcut that makes this frosty cocktail even easier to pull off. (Use about 12 oz. frozen pineapple chunks and start at Step 2.) You can also use drained canned pineapple in 100% juice (save the juice for a smoothie!). Want to go fresh? Learn how:

My blender jar won’t fit in the freezer. What should I do?

Transfer the blended mixture to a freezer-safe container or resealable bag, freeze until thickened, then return it to the blender and blend again before serving. Need a new blender? Find our favorite here:

Can I make it less boozy?

The white rum is necessary for balance, but you can certainly skip the floater for a lighter version. For a totally spirit-free version, try Derek Brown’s recipe on Epicurious, which balances the pineapple and coconut with cane syrup and a splash of apple cider vinegar:

Watch Brad make piña coladas →

• Vitamix 5200 Blender

  $500 $430 At Amazon

• Coco Lopez Coconut Cream

  $23 At Amazon

• Luxardo Maraschino Cherries

  $24 At Amazon

Vitamix 5200 Blender

$500 $430 At Amazon

Coco Lopez Coconut Cream

$23 At Amazon

Luxardo Maraschino Cherries

$24 At Amazon

Recipe information

• Total Time

  3 hours 45 minutes

• Yield

  4 servings

Total Time

3 hours 45 minutes

Yield

4 servings

Ingredients

½

6

2

8

1

2

3

Need to make a substitution?

Preparation

1. Step 1

   Place ½ medium ripe pineapple (about 1¼ lb.), peeled, cored, cut into 1½" pieces (2–2½ cups) in a resealable plastic bag, laying them flat. Freeze until solid, at least 3 hours.

   Step 2

   Purée frozen pineapple, 6 oz. sweetened cream of coconut, 2 oz. unsweetened coconut milk, 8 oz. white rum, 1 oz. fresh lime juice, and 3 cups ice in a blender until smooth. Transfer blender jar to freezer; freeze until mixture is thickened (it should be the consistency of a milkshake), 25–35 minutes.

   Step 3

   Blend again until mixture is the perfect slushy frozen drink consistency. Divide among 4 glasses. Top off each with ½ oz. dark rum (if using) and garnish each with a maraschino cherry and a lime wedge.

   Do Ahead: Pineapple can be chopped 3 months ahead; keep frozen. Piña colada can stay in freezer up to 4 hours after first blend.

   Editor’s note: This piña colada cocktail recipe was first printed in February 2016. Head this way for more of our best summer cocktails →

Step 1

Place ½ medium ripe pineapple (about 1¼ lb.), peeled, cored, cut into 1½" pieces (2–2½ cups) in a resealable plastic bag, laying them flat. Freeze until solid, at least 3 hours.

Step 2

Purée frozen pineapple, 6 oz. sweetened cream of coconut, 2 oz. unsweetened coconut milk, 8 oz. white rum, 1 oz. fresh lime juice, and 3 cups ice in a blender until smooth. Transfer blender jar to freezer; freeze until mixture is thickened (it should be the consistency of a milkshake), 25–35 minutes.

Step 3

Blend again until mixture is the perfect slushy frozen drink consistency. Divide among 4 glasses. Top off each with ½ oz. dark rum (if using) and garnish each with a maraschino cherry and a lime wedge.

Do Ahead: Pineapple can be chopped 3 months ahead; keep frozen. Piña colada can stay in freezer up to 4 hours after first blend.

Editor’s note: This piña colada cocktail recipe was first printed in February 2016. Head this way for more of our best summer cocktails →

Recipe notes